Combining difference in difference and matching for panel data analysis. Difference in differences estimation in stata youtube. Matching methods improve the validity of causal inference by reducing model dependence and offering intuitive diagnostics. Sep 25, 2015 propensity score matching can identify treatment effects in a selection on observables context. Diff indiff controlling for covariates, kernelbased propensity score matching. Simplifying the estimation of differenceindifferences. We evaluate the impact of a city level intervention. Matched difference in differences is one example of combining methods. A caliper which means the maximum tolerated difference between matched subjects in a nonperfect matching intention is frequently set at 0. Difference in differences treatment effects did have been widely used when. Install a userwritten stata program called psmatch2 ssc install. Github thomasgstewartpropensityscorematchinginstata. Written permission must be obtained from stata corporation if you wish to make electronic copies of the insertions. I need to know how can i combine in stata the did difference in difference model with the psm propensity score matching with crosssectional data.
Aug 01, 2016 the differenceindifference estimator or the double difference estimators is given by. Learn how to estimate treatment effects using propensityscore matching in stata. Please refer to the stata manuals and online help for more information. Variables and items that would change for your program are in lower case and not bold.
The regression approach dd sd1 sd0 b thus, under the weaker type i identification assumptions, the effect of the treatment on the treated att is given by the regression coefficient. In the spirit of the difference in difference method, we first difference the outcomes to remove the fixed effects. The estimation of causal effects by differenceindifference. However, previous simulations suggest that this approach does not always eliminate or reduce bias, and it is not clear when and why. While they have become a part of the standard tool kit across disciplines, matching methods are rarely used when analyzing timeseries crosssectional data. Stata module for regression discontinuity estimation. Probably the simplest way to do that is to generate a matchgroup variable that identifies the matched pairs or triples or whatever. The differenceindifferences coefficient is, which indicates how the effect of kids changed after the eitc went into effect. I need to know how can i combine in stata the did differenceindifference model with the psm propensity score matching with crosssectional data. How to deal with varying treatment time and duration. Departments of sociology and statistics, indiana university 2016 stata conference from stata users group. An introduction to implementing difference in differences regressions in stata.
Matching is consistent if and only if selection is due to transitory shocks. You need to incorporate the matching into the analysis. This module should be installed from within stata by typing ssc install diff. Run the following command in stata to load an example data set. Treatmenteffects estimators allow us to estimate the causal effect of a treatment on. Single diff in diff, diff in diff controlling for covariates, kernelbased propensity score matching diff in diff, and the quantile diff in diff. This lecture is part 9 of the propensity scores and related methods series presented and organized by robert greevy within vanderbilt universitys center for health services research. Differences in differences animation beginner youtube.
Explanatory comments and documentation begin with asterisks. Nov 15, 2011 the estimation of causal effects by difference in difference methods presents a brief overview of the literature on the difference in difference estimation strategy and discusses major issues mainly using a treatment effect perspective that allows more general considerations than the classical regression formulation that still dominates the. Matching on two categorical variables, such as sex and race, isnt much more difficult. Aug 24, 2015 matching subjects based on a single binary variable, such as sex, is simple.
Stata ic can have at most 798 righthandside variables in a model. Which biostatistical software is particularly good for propensity score matching. However, matching has been used typically in crosssectional data analysis. It involves comparing measurements before and after a treatment occurs hence, the growth rate in both a group that received the treatment, and an otherwise comparable group that did not. Can i truly say that i did propensity score matching and then did difference in difference by just running diff and supplying it with control variables. I found some discussions of did methods in the statalist archive, such as this.
Graphical demonstration of difference in differences. Controlled variables included medical security, and general and occupational health behaviour during 201214. The dd estimate is the quantity in the lower right hand box, which can be thought of either as the change in the difference between groups across time, or the change across time in the difference between groups. Researchers should be aware of the threat of regression to the mean when constructing matched samples for difference. But at least this is much less than the difference of 12. Matching on continuous variables, such as age or weight, can be trickier because of the sparsity of the data. Propensity score matching meets differenceindifferences. We used propensity score matching psm and differenceindifference did methods to examine potential mechanisms by controlling for the healthy migrant hypothesis. Matching is often done via propensity score matching pscore etc. Using propensity scores in differenceindifferences models. Newest differenceindifference questions cross validated.
The impact evaluation book has a section on mixed methods that gives a really good treatment of the power of using both psm and dd. Statalist stata implementation of differenceindifferences. Stata module to perform differences in differences estimation. Evaluating the foreign ownership wage premium using a. Stata does not have a built in command for propensity score matching, a nonexperimental method of sampling that produces a control group whose distribution of covariates is similar to that of the treated group. Difference in differences combined with matching on pretreatment outcomes is a popular method for addressing nonparallel trends between a treatment and control group.
Combining di erenceindi erence and matching for panel. Villa brooks world poverty institute university of manchester manchester, uk. In our last post, we introduced the concept of treatment effects and demonstrated four of the treatmenteffects estimators that were introduced in stata. Stata module to perform differences in differences.
Papers can be downloaded free of charge from the diw berlin website. The stata command flexpaneldid for matching and diffindiff with panel data. The result for the pre treatment variable re75 is a socalled pre program test. Probably the simplest way to do that is to generate a match group variable that identifies the matched pairs or triples or whatever. Then we apply matching on the differenced outcomes at each wave except the first one. However, there are several userwritten modules for this method. Matching, regression discontinuity, difference in differences.
In this paper, we extend matching to panel data analysis. A good difference in difference analysis involves matching of the control and treatment groups, so that they are very similar in every possible way, except receiving the treatment. Matched difference in differences statalist the stata forum. It is checked if the matching results in a balancing of the original level of income before the treatment. The articles appearing in the stata journal may be copied or reproduced as printed copies, in whole or in part, as long as any copy or reproduction includes attribution to both 1 the author and 2 the stata journal. Propensity score matching and difference in differences. This paper explains the insights of the stata s user written command diff for. Stata implementation of differenceindifferences with binary outcomes. Combining di erence in di erence and matching for panel data analysis. Pdf how to deal with varying treatment time and duration. Differencesindifferences is a popular quasiexperimental methodology used to estimate causal effects from longitudinal observational data.
Simplifying the estimation of differenceindifferences treatment effects. Weihua an additional contact information weihua an. Dec 01, 2014 standard differenceindifferences designs. Stata ic allows datasets with as many as 2,048 variables, and the maximum number of observations is 2.
Combining di erenceindi erence and matching for panel data analysis weihua an departments of sociology and statistics indiana university. In its simplest form, the dd design can be illustrated in a 2. It is fairly simple to implement and there are enough options to work with. The coefficient for did is the differencesindifferences estimator. Combining differenceindifference and matching for panel. Apr 01, 2018 an introduction to implementing difference in differences regressions in stata.
Single diffindiff, diffindiff controlling for covariates, kernelbased propensity score matching diffindiff, and the quantile diffindiff. We thus strongly recommend switching from psmatch2 to teffects psmatch, and this article will help you make the transition. If we drop either the middle term or the last term, we obtain one of the dd estimates described in the previous paragraph. Which biostatistical software is particularly good for.
This often turns out to make a significant difference, and sometimes in surprising ways. Jun 29, 2018 when treatment assignment is correlated with preperiod trend only, the unmatched analysis is biased, and matching units on preperiod level or trend does not introduce additional bias. In this paper, the statas command diff is explained and some details on its. In this article, i present the features of the userwritten command diff, which estimates difference in differences did treatment effects. Often abbreviated did or dd, this is a technique for inferring causality from observational data. Today, we will talk about two more treatmenteffects estimators that use matching. Sep 29, 2016 just found these very clear and pedagogical slides from the centre for research on impact evaluation europea commission dealing with propensity score matching psm and difference in differences did slides and for those using stata, dont forget psmatch2 for psm and diff for did. Keywords st0424, diff, differenceindifferences, causal inference, kernel. I would like to know if any of you have used this command. Simplifying the estimation of difference in differences treatment. Using medicaid claims data from oregon, we systematically vary the distribution of two key. Using stata to matchmerge two files1 following is an example of matching two files with stata. An introduction to propensity score matching in stata. The command is equipped with an attractive set of options.
1147 726 1393 1255 399 423 1214 1177 1128 860 572 717 301 131 46 344 861 1526 455 1115 872 30 374 1500 1644 1109 190 500 573 1293 1377 1573 869 750 1070 260 478 721 432 264 504 1199 708 1064 1339